| The Free Site | vBuddy - promote your website free | Cheap Web Hosting - starting at $5 |
INTRODUCTORY STUDY
Communism has proved yet another fact difficult to deny, namely that, on principle,
as an extension of the atheist revolutionary "fundamentalism," it
conducted the same policy adverse to religion on two different planes. The
former is the one of faith, where they act as atheists, pursuing to destroy
God's presence in the soul and mind of people, to destroy the image of Homo
religiosus. In this respect, the communists took the path of the deicide,
by ideologically demolishing faith but also by eliminating or physically isolating
the believers and their shepherds from society, from the national communities
of the whole world. The latter plane is the one of the church institution,
i.e. the plane of the legal status of denominations, of the relations with
the State, of the fortunes, of their recognition irrespective of the degree
of autonomy or of the extreme subordinations accepted under treaties, concordats
or other modalities that do not run counter to the constitutional order (cults
not accepted by the law).
Both planes and the repressive, direct or dissimulated measures deriving therefrom
have been running counter to the human rights principles, to the freedom of
conscience and to the exercise of these freedoms.
20th century Romania experienced one totalitarian regime. It was the one of
communist origin and Soviet inspiration, extending between. 23 August 1944
and December 1989. The communist totalitarian regime gradually acquired a
state terrorist character, due to the "participation" imposed by
different methods that ran counter to human rights and involved all institutions
of the State in the monitoring and repression of the country's own citizens
(a genuine interpretation of the human rights attests the citizens' millenary
religious and even Christian origin)1.
Through internationalist extensions, these methods infringed upon religious
freedoms in the countries annexed or caught in their influence sphere.
In keeping with the so-called radical revolutionary theory implemented most
often through coups d'etat, the entire population was forced through blackmail
and terror (as it did not have freely acquiesced organization alternatives)
to become obedient versus the goals pursued by the establishment, by its universal
ideology, by the single parties - instruments for putting into practice the
destruction of the "class enemies." They were geared to "re-educating"
the whole society. But terror was exercised notably against religion and the
representatives of the traditional Churches, deemed "conservative"
and "reactionary." Tragic evidence is to be found in the history
of communist revolutions (whatever name they might have taken) from the French
Revolution and what it inspired - 1848, the Paris Commune, the anti-Christian
struggle methods in Latin America against the "Colonial Church"
and the promotion of "Liberation Theology", the strategy of fragmenting
the Christian unity into countless sects in the two Americas - to the forms
instituted by totalitarian communist revolutionarism beginning in 1917 in
Russia and followed by the vast complementary experiments in Asia and particularly
in the East-European countries, from 1944 to 1984-1990. The communist spirit
that inspired the ideology of the "world revolution" influenced
to a large extent the world control of the anti-religious and especially anti-Christian
struggle either through the policy conducted by the Komintern (Kominform),
by the "peace movement," by other forms of the atheist "world
solidarity." Often the anti-religious policy ran hand in hand with the
interests of the states, with the national movements and with the manipulation
of communities by esoteric groups.
Such states of affairs generated resistance on the part of religious institutions
everywhere even when they had to accept compromises with the authorities in
the totalitarian communist countries. This holds true for the Orthodox. Catholic,
Buddhist and, to a lesser extent, the Muslim, Mosaic or Protestant Churches.
A highly important support resided in the preservation of religiosity as a
form of the everyday culture, from intimate inner feelings to the hidden events
(baptisms, weddings, and funerals with religious rituals) or even ones happening
in public (as in the communist Tibet), to the worst communist repression,
leading to a minimal survival of faith in Albania, where all structures of
the religious life were destroyed, or in the USSR, which for 70-80 years was
the bastion of the Marxist-Leninist anti-religious struggle in its spheres
of influence: states, peoples, intellectuals, universities, trade unions,
allegedly ecumenical organizations etc. Francois Furet emphasizes H. Arendt's
assertion: Concentration camps reveal the essence of totalitarianism, rounding
it off to the effect that the basic inhumanity of these ideological regimes
has to be opposed to the Divine transcendence, as Gurian pertinently shows.
The latter upholds that the European intellectual left, as a whole, is antifascist,
not anti totalitarian. That is why he thinks highly of George Orwell, the
author of the well-known novel 1984. written back in 1949 and, equally, of
Raymond Aron, who are exceptions from the intelligentsia's time-serving conformism,
owing to their analytical capacity.
One should not overlook, however, the role H. Arendt assigned to terror under
totalitarianism, to total, terror as a law governing the movement of History
under Bolshevism, or of Nature with the Nazis, replacing the positive laws;
total terror becomes an essence of government and a principle of movement.
The true essence of all Ideologies was revealed by the role it plays in the
totalitarian domination machinery, becoming independent from the other human
experiences.
The totalitarian regime destroyed all the social, juridical and political
traditions of the country (adding to which are the spiritual ones - A.A.).
The present dictionary shows that in any country where the communist regime
is enforced, it expresses state terrorist totalitarianism and that destruction
of religion is one of the major goals pursued with a steadfastness rarely
met in world history, even though it should have waited one more century before
reaching the deepest roots of religion as a whole and of Christianity in particular.
After the 20th century atheist experiences, we are recording today the following
values regarding the spread of Christianity in the world:
1) Catholics - 872, 104, 000 out of whom: Roman-Catholics - 862, 422, 000
and Uniates (Eastern) - 9, 682, 00
2) Protestants - 339, 990, 000 out of whom: the United Church (Reformed and
Lutheran) - 65, 400, 000; Lutherans - 44, 900, 000; Reformed / Presbyterians
- 43, 500, 000; Methodists - 31, 650, 000; Pentecostals
- 59, 000, 000; Holiness - 6, 125, 000; Adventists - 6, 200, 000; Congregational
- 2, 900, 000; Anabaptists (Mennonites) - 1, 250, 000; Moravians - 750, 000;
Quakers - 500, 000; and various (other Neoprotestant sects) - 27, 475, 000.
3) Orthodox - 139, 380, 000, out of whom: Russians - 92, 542, 000; Romanians
-18, 000, 000; Greeks - 13, 430, 000; Serbs - 8, 100, 000; various - 7, 326,
000
4) Anglicans - 52, 500, 000
5) Monophysites - 30, 267, 000 out of whom: Ethiopians - 17, 333, 000; Coptic
- 7, 919, 000; Armenians - 3, 350, 000; Syrians - 1, 665, 000
6) Nestorian Church: close to Protestants - 30, 500, 000 and close to Catholicism
- 14, 600, 000.
After the end of World War II, countries such as Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia,
Poland, Romania, Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Yugoslavia and a good part of
Germany's territory (up to Berlin) remained under the influence and direct
control of the former USSR.
The anti-religious policy of the occupiers manifested itself immediately after
August 1944 and especially after 1945, in different conditions, according
to the prevailing structure of the religious denominations.
In Russia, after 1917, the Bolshevik party was not late in starting the religious
repression of the Orthodox Church (O.C.) and then against the other denominations
in the territory of the USSR.
Here below are a few aspects of the Bolshevik repression against religion
and churches:
a) After the communist revolution of February 1917, an all-Russia Synod is
held, which restores the independence of the patriarch from the state (autocephaly).
b) The October 1917 revolution triggers the collapse of the O.C.'s unity,
the secularization and bullying of millions of believers, the ousting of ecclesiastical
personalities and the subordination of the Church.
c) The action of secularizing the Russian intelligentsia and the workers had
notable antecedents dating to the late 19th century (see the theories of the
communist Gramsci).
d) The period 1918-1948 (the decree on the separation of the Church from the
State, and not of the legal status) records a ruthless struggle against the
O.C. and the seizure of all assets (from all denominations). In 1927, Metropolitan
Sergey recognizes the authority of the Soviets and the opposition against
the communist totalitarian State comes to an end.
e) The repression - 150 bishops interned in the camps on the White Sea coast;
wide-scope atheist campaign; between 1917 and 1923 (the "Lenin epoch")
14,590.000 persons were victimized, including 40,000 priests; between 1924
and 1947 there died ca. 36,000,000 people, including 5,000 priests (by virtue
of the Kirov law which provided for summary trial and rapid execution, a law
promoted in 1794 by Couthon for the "enemies" of the French Revolution).
f) The world's biggest Orthodox Cathedral, inaugurated in 1883 (the Cathedral
of Christ the Saviour), which had taken 45 years to build, is pulled down
in 1931, in just four months, on Stalin's order. Worth mentioning from among
its riches are: the central dome covered with 173 tons of copper; the massive
cross which took the height of the monument to 103 m.; 14 bells, with the
central one, the Tsar's bell, weighing 24 tons; 12 bronze gates, 48 very tall
bas-reliefs; 3000 candlesticks; a monumental iconostasis decorated with emeralds
and gold, icons, over 170 commemorative marble plates etc.
g) A report submitted to Boris Yeltsin by Iakovlev, who headed the Commission
for the Rehabilitation of Political Victims, shows that 200,000 clerics were
martyred and 500,000 were detained and deported between 1917 and 1980. By
1937, 136,900 clergy had been imprisoned and 85,000 had been assassinated.
In 1938, 28,000 were arrested and 21,500 were executed. In 1922 alone, they
assassinated 8,000 prelates, including Metropolitan Beniamin, following the
Bolshevik rulers' pressures with a view to taking over the church treasure
estimated at ca. 300 million dollars. Current assets of the Church were distributed
to the poor but the very precious ecclesiastical objects were retained by
the "new power." In Bessarabia (which after the occupation became
the Moldavian Soviet Socialist Republic), in 1944-1945 there existed 24 monasteries
and hermitages (9 for nuns and 15 for monks) with 1007 nuns and 440 monks.
In 1954 there Were 7 monasteries with monks and 8 for nuns, the personnel
aggregating 1393 persons, down from 2414 in 1925 (when it was already reduced
following the repression in the first seven years of Bolshevism). The data
comes from the review Destin romanesc (Romanian Destiny), 4/1996, no. 12,
pp. 85-100. The assets seized from the O.C. were worth a fabulous 2.5 billion
gold rubles. 40,000 churches and half the number of mosques and synagogues
were destroyed.
h) The clergy were compromised through the KGB's recruitment (Iakovlev s report
showed that many members of the clergy had acted against their conscience)
under reprisals, so that they can hardly be singled out for reproaches7.
i) The communists started a furious action to instill atheism into the people's
conscience, from children to the elderly, through the vilest practices of
slandering faith (which, as a matter of fact, were found among the crimes
perpetrated b\ the terrorist re-education organized in the prisons in Romania
where the young people of the 1948 generation were detained): publication
of atheist literature, forms of propagandist^ derision of the worship forms,
the ban on religion in schools, encouragement of blasphemies notably against
the Christian religion, and so on.
j) Between 1959 and 1964, under Khrushchev, the repression was revived: out
of 20,000 churches there remained 13, out of 77 monasteries there were left
17, five out of eight seminaries were shut down, and the Council of Religious
Affairs was set up to intensify state control over the Church; in 1964-1989
people were arrested and interned in psychiatric hospitals; dissidence surfaced
among the clergy. I. Andropov, the former chairman of the KGB, infiltrated
the Church as part of a demolishing diversion, i.e. promotion of the actions
characteristic of a communist variant of the "Liberation Theology"
within the traditional Church, which after decades of terror was anyway helpless.
k) It is worth mentioning that the notorious Basic Guidelines of the NKVD
for the countries in the Soviet orbit (Moscow, 2 June, 1947 [top secret] K-AA/CC
113, Index NK/003/47), item 34, "recommended" special attention
to be paid to churches. Cultural-educational activity has to be so directed
as to generate antipathy for the churches. It is necessary to monitor the
church printing houses, the archives, and the content of sermons, of songs,
of religious education and of burial ceremonies. That was in 1947, at the
outset of anti-religious measures in the countries occupied by the Soviets.
The Soviet model was to be forced upon the countries in eastern Europe and
even on those in Asia (Tibet), North Korea, Mongolia, China, Cuba, etc., in
keeping with the strategic, confessional or political particularities.
- The repression in Bulgaria (1948-1963) was more restrained and the Uniate
Church remained relatively autonomous.
- In Albania, the repression was ruthless, one may say it was even absolute
with regard to the church institution. Even among the Muslims there were thousands
of persecuted people.
- In the Catholic countries, the Roman-Catholic Church was sometimes tolerated
while at other times it was intimidated. Certain compromises were made in
Hungary, Poland, Czechoslovakia and the Baltic countries. The Iron Curtain
functioned in its most sensitive spots.
- The Protestant Church was obedient towards the state", which also explains
the low number of victims.
During the Vatican Council II, 1962-1965, there were 150 Catholic bishops
in the whole communist world, but the proceedings were attended by few bishops
and by none from Russia, Romania, China or North Vietnam. The Orthodox Patriarch
(Constantinopolitan) and the Ecumenical Council of Churches (a Soviet creation)
failed to send observers.
In Romania, the traditional churches and the cults were forced to take over
the Soviet subordination system imposed by the Communist Party (although the
autocephaly principle was encroached upon). Most of the quite large Orthodox
population was subjected to unfailing terror, given the deep roots the Orthodox
faith had in the people's conscience and, on the other hand, the fact that
the Romanian right wing was pervaded by the Christian spirit. The four-party
"Front" that assumed the power after 23 August 1944 did not want
to see anticommunist resistance movements based on connections that could
become operational with all the other Eastern countries invaded by the Red
Army.
The Soviet totalitarianism also had a long-standing experience in point of
imposing its programme on other countries (within the Soviet Union and outside
it through the Komintern and through other allegedly ecumenical networks of
influence).
The anti-religious repression model applied in Romania, between 1944 and 1989,
basically reproduced the ideology and policy of the Communist Party of the
Soviet Union and of the NKVD.
Here are the main components of the repressive policy.
1) The concern over forming a communist party which was absolutely missing.
The method? Rallying those who wanted power, the undecided, the ignorant and
those considered as "compromised", misleading them with "democratic"
promises.
In all the major fields of the intellectual life were created "democratic,"
tolerant organizations "open to collaboration." This is how associations
of the Writers, Jurists, the united trade union movement, the Progressive
Youth, the National Democratic Front, the Democratic Community of Jews and
other such organizations came into being.
For the Orthodox clergy, the Democratic Union of Priests was set up after
March 1945.
2) The position of minister at the Department of Religions was held in turn
by Gheorghe Pop, Constantin Burducea, the priest of a commune parish (March
1945 -April 1946) and Stanciu Stoian, who ensured the interference -of the
Sovietized state in the activity of the churches; the persecution of the clergy
began as early as 1945.
3) After Ion Antonescu's arrest, the new government decided to send to prison
most of the ethnic Germans who were citizens of Romania; they organized the
first detention camps for the enemies of the Soviet-type regime, including
many priests; the Church underwent massive purges, for different reasons that
served as pretext for reducing the ecclesiastical personnel; application of
the obligations deriving from the Armistice Agreement, of the Allied Control
Commission in Romania which, although it was quadripartite, was dominated
by the Soviets, of the Paris Peace treaty, accompanied by complementary documents
or requirements related to the special circumstances (the NKVD Protocol, orders
brought by the Soviet advisers directly from Moscow, the "visits"
paid by Andrei Ianuarevich Vyshinski etc.).
4) In 1948, confessional schools were closed down; a sustained anti-religious
press campaign was conducted; on 1 December 1948, under Decree no. 358 the
Greek-Catholic Church (united with Rome) was dissolved. The measure was dictated
by the politburo of the Romanian Communist Party and imposed arbitrarily (the
RCP resolution was made by Gheorghe Gheorghiu-Dej, Teohari Georgescu, Ana
Pauker, Vasile Luca and Emil Bodnaras, the last two having direct responsibilities
for the "religious policy").
Moreover, the episcopal seats of the Roman-Catholic Church were reduced from
6 to 2.
Monastic life in the traditional churches was restricted almost down to nonexistence.
The measures were stepped up after the monarchy had been abolished (1947),
concurrently with the start of the campaign of arresting the participants
in the anticommunist resistance movement (about 200 thousand detainees and
five times as many people subjected to the Securitate investigations), reaching
nationwide proportions by 1964. The Patriarch of the Orthodox Church died
while in office in 1948. Many bishops of the Christian church were dispossessed
of their seats and arrested, after which they died, or were just purged or
subjected to forms of house arrest.
In July 1948, an all-Orthodox Conference was held at the level of metropolitans
in the Orthodox countries under Soviet occupation. On 19 July 1948 the concordat
with the Vatican was denounced, religion was eliminated from schools, on the
basis of the new education law, the fortunes of these schools were confiscated,
and a new law on the cults was passed, providing for the restriction of areas
in the possession of the traditional churches (mostly the Orthodox Church).
Previously, several bishops and vicars of the O.C. had been deprived of their
dioceses, some being even isolated in monasteries, just like the Roman-Catholic
and Greek-Catholic ones, while others were relegated to the lower ecclesiastical
echelons.
5) Arrests were made among the ecclesiastical personnel of the Orthodox Church,
Romania's majority church, as well as among the personnel of the other two
traditional churches. Gradually, the O.C. was dispossessed of the inherited
assets, of fields and buildings, through a policy of secularization. Later
arrests were operated also among other cults. After 1944 in Romania there
existed 5 metropolitan seats (of Ungro-Vlahia, Moldavia, Transylvania, Oltenia
and Banat), 9 archbishoprics and 12 bishoprics.
6) A cursory statistic of the data contained in the Dictionary indicates certain
evaluations regarding the ordeals the ecclesiastical personnel in Romania
was subjected to in the totalitarian period.
Detained ecclesiastical personnel surveyed in the Dictionary (2544 persons):
• Detained priests:
- Orthodox priests 1,888
- Greek-Catholic (Uniate) 235
- Roman-Catholic 172
- Protestant pastors 67
- Neoprotestant 25
- Muslim 23
- Mosaic 13
• Church chanters - 49
• Ecclesiastical personnel whose religion was not identified - approximately
100
In interpreting the data in the Dictionary, the figures will be referred to
the ecclesiastical personnel of the respective cults before 1948.
Orthodox prelates (metropolitans and bishops) not comprised in the Dictionary
(the prelates of the c .her cults are presented in the Dictionary):
• Deprived of their seats - 17
• Exiled- 15
Purged priests and church chanters (belonging to the various denominations):
• Priests (under Law no. 139/1947, art. 5) - 966
• Church chanters (under Law no. 146 bis/1947) - 614
• Under the same laws 11 members of the administrative personnel were
purged.
Monks who participated in the National Resistance Movement (not included in
the Dictionary): 60
• According to Radu Ciuceanu, the situation of the monks who supported
the NRM in Oltenia was the following: Tismana Monastery - 9, Lainici - 5,
Turnu - 4, Stanisoara - 6, Govora-St. Filofteia - 2, Dintr-un Lemn - 2, Polovraci
- 3, Bradet - 1, Rasca -3, Cozia - 3, Frasinei - 6, Bistrita - 2, Gura Motrului
- 2.
7) The ecclesiastical corps was subjected to very harsh investigation, detention
and torture methods as well as to recruitment actions by the bodies of the
Ministry of Internal Affairs. The pressures were meant to make them abjure
their faith, the church and God, to fall prey to libertinism and corruption.
That influenced the evolution of the ecclesiastical corps.
Considering that admission to the Theological Institute, accession to a doctor's
degree and to hierarchical positions depended on criteria pertaining to the
"personal dossier" or to one's acceptance of political interferences,
we shall realize that the communist regime conducted a continuous straggle
to destabilize the religious institution. This straggle acquired different
nuances depending on the denomination, on the nation involved, on the period
of time when it was active among the intellectuals or the laymen during the
long domination of communist totalitarianism.
The Gendarmerie and the political police were ordered to watch the religious
events and especially the political manifestations of the clergy since the
RCP leadership knew all the clergy were inimical to the regime established
after 1944. Order no. 7424/1947 issued by the Bucharest Regional Security
Inspectorate requested not only the surveillance of priests but also the drawing
up of personal cards, according to a model, which had to be submitted to the
repression bodies by 1 December 1947". Unfortunately the selection of
documents and of the content is rather inconsistent, often biased, the sources
cited dating from the communist period.
8) The massive destruction of churches (mostly the Orthodox ones but also
mosques and synagogues - see Lucian Schwartz and Aristide Streja's recent
work The Synagogues in Romania during the Communist Period, 1997) rounded
off the pattern of the anti -religious repression exerted by the communists.
Of course, there also existed some reparatory acts, notably in relation to
historical monuments belonging to the heritage and being part of the national
history or of the material value proper (the tourism industry, the diplomatic
image).
9) There existed significant cases of conversion during detention, of secret
consecration of the Greek-Catholic and Roman-Catholic bishops, as well as
cases of former prisoners who after their release became priests or monks
and were again arrested, just as there were many who died in prison or in
the "freedom" of unclear circumstances (in the anticommunist resistance
straggle).
A principle of the moral theology teaches us that great fear (the darkening
of the mind in face of an imminent evil) invalidates the act. But aren 7 deportation,
imprisonment and death reasons for serious fear'2'! Don't they also explain
the cases of those who were subdued?
10) A special case is represented by the tragedy of the Christian population
that remained in the USSR (such as in the Moldavian SSR which returned to
Romania in 1941-1944 and then remained under occupation).
We are in possession of a list of the ecclesiastical personnel in Bessarabia
who sought refuge in Romania (those of them who have been detected by now).
Many ended up in the Romanian prisons.
11) The scope of the repression grows and religious interdictions prevent
and discourage any public manifestation (by "top secret order" no.
27936 of December 1948). The ideological blaming of these customs of a religious
nature generates the phenomenon of avoidance or even "secrecy" -
religious weddings, baptisms, funerals with religious ritual, attendance of
religious service, observance of religious holidays, etc. The population often
encroached upon these restrictions, which led to the infiltration of the Churches
and of the ecclesiastical personnel by informers, to the end of controlling
the "re-education" pursued by the atheist communist regime.
The blame put on party members, on people working in schools, military units
or official institutions amounted to a serious warning. The active censoring
of the mass media and of the printed matter put out by the metropolitan publishing
houses was a strict rule.
12) For the purpose of approximate evaluations, in the absence of official
data, we studied the monographic work of the priest Dr loan Dura, Romanian
Monasticism between 1948 and 1989 (collection "Testimonies"), Harisma
Publishing House, 1994; the research was conducted by our collaborator Virgil
Constantinescu (a member of the Association of Former Political Detainees
in Romania).
Data vvere collected regarding the monastic establishments (monasteries, hermitages,
succursal monasteries, chapels) as well as the number of those who lived there
(monks, nuns, brothers). The estimates were put forth by officials or apparently
credible publications, therefore being determined by the level of information
and the circumstances in which they were made public (at home or abroad),
as well as by the moment between 1949 and 1989 when they were issued, that
having been a period marked by the known repressive events. Here below is
a synthesis with the figures between brackets indicating contradictory presentations
made in the same year and different sources.
Monachal establishments
(the figures vary depending on where
and when they were made public):
1955 - 200
1956 - 188
1957 - 191 (197) (197) (200)
1960 - 250 (123) (250) (123)
1961 - 200
1981 - 147 (100)(100)(130)
1986 - 100 (140) (103) (100)
1987 - 114(130)
1989 - 114 (150) (100) (150)
The number of monks and nuns:
1949 - 164 (in monastic seminaries and monasteries)
1951 - 10, 000 [?]
1953 - 6, 000 (7,000) (7,000)
1955 - 7, 500 (3 monastic seminaries)(7,000) (7,500)
1956 - 6, 156 + 56 seminaries
1957 - 6, 011 (6, 011 + 106 schools and workshops) (7,000) (6,500) decree
no. 410 on the reduction of monachal units (2, 000) (1,000) (2,000)
1961 - 7, 000
1966 - 2, 000
1968 - 2, 500
1969 - 2, 500 (3,000) (2,068)
Neither after 1989 have we found any official statistics or statistics compiled
on the basis of research.
In the review Vestitorul Ortodoxiei of October 1995, p. 4, there is a synthesis
(Gh. Vasilescu) which indicates several redistributions of the dioceses compared
to 1925 (Greater Romania) but not also the number of churches or servants
between 1944 and 1989. Compared to 1925 (18 dioceses), in 1947 there is the
same number, while for 1995 there is mention of 21 dioceses. Yet in 1950 there
existed 12 dioceses, then 13 within the same 5 metropolitan bishoprics. In
1925 there were 9,067 priests and in 1995 - 8,729, although the number of
churches went up from 10,735 in 1925 to 12,546 in 1995, the number of priests
being sensibly smaller in 1995 than in 1925 (despite the natural population
growth).
We infer that for the growing population of the country,-which in 1995 needed
21 dioceses, after 1950 there were only 12-13 Orthodox dioceses. This situation
lasted until 1990 (in 1944, 2 dioceses were lost with the territories robbed
from Romania and in 1947 there existed the same 18 dioceses). It is natural
for us to note the sharp fall in the number of priests, dioceses and churches
between 1948 and 1989 but also the fact that most of the population kept up
the light of faith.
13) The persons held in custody, including prelates or theologians, experienced
physical and mental torture, being subjected to various methods of re-education
- the final goal of the communist revolution.
The main methods were:
investigations by the political police (violent in most cases);
penitentiary punishments (long individual isolation without food or with a
starvation regimen, regular beatings):
the so-called self-re-education (the detainees were forced to give up their
anticommunist activities and outlook through the prison regime imposed by
the political police, using the methods of ideological persuasion - books,
newspapers, parcels - for self-denunciation at Suceava, Targsor or Gherla.
for young people, students, workers and peasants, concomitantly with enrollment
- at Suceava - in the Organization of Detainees with Communist Convictions,
which had been set up in order to reform the masses of detainees;
the "re-education" of the prelates belonging to the main traditional
Churches, who were not sentenced but were forced by all means of persuasion
to abjure their beliefs concerning the shepherding of the faithful population,
and of the representatives of the banned denominations;
the re-education based on terror organized by the higher echelons of the political
police or of the penitentiaries who resorted to the tactic of pitting the
detainees against each other and inciting them to violence, to giving up their
beliefs and providing information on the anticommunist resistance. Pitesti,
Gherla and the Canal;
the "self-analysis" practiced at Aiud under the guidance of an "operative
group" made up of 16 political police officers, the detainees having
to expose themselves and to disown, publicly and in writing, their anticommunist
beliefs;
the re-education through work at the labour camps at the Canal, Salcia, Periprava,
the Cavnic and Baia Sprie mines, which meant physical and moral destruction
(mention is made of a special brigade made up of about 40 priests who were
part of the colonies at the Canal);
re-education through isolation (after release) based on house arrest; cooperation
with the political police; deportation; continuous harassment, etc. The population
was thus subdued by an intensified "atheist education."
The total number of victims of the anticommunist struggle, from 1944 till
1989 - people who died, were assassinated, disappeared or were deported -
is not known, just like the specific data concerning the ecclesiastical personnel
of any denomination. We hope this Dictionary will help provide new documentary
information.
Whatever their results, these methods contributed to the physical destruction
of many detainees and, especially, to perverting some of them, who we do not
think we are entitled to blame, since millions of party members and free citizens
accepted to collaborate, without having passed - many of them - through the
Caudine Forks of detention, blackmail and systematic harassment.
The Dictionary of Ecclesiastical Personnel Imprisoned under the Communist Regime
This dictionary
was compiled as part of the thematic research programme of the National Institute
for the Study of Totalitarianism with regard to the Violation of Human Rights
under the communist totalitarian regime (coordinator Paul Caravia), which
began in 1995 at the same time with other subthemes.
In collecting and organizing the data several stages were covered. In 1990-1992,
the contributors to the Romanian Parliament's former 14th Commission for abuses,
Gheorghe F. Anghelescu and Octavian Roske, sent all Cults and diocesan centres
in this country a form requesting data on the religious repression. They returned
memorandums and reports on the violation of the right to faith, to a religion
of one's own choice.
At the same time, after 1990 a Reflection Group for the Renewal of the Church
functioned for a while, independently trying to collect oral data on the detention
of clergy belonging to various denominations, under the communist regime.
The few data gathered were not made public.
A group of former political detainees, members of the Association of Former
Political Detainees in Romania (AFDPR), including Cicerone Ionitoiu (who at
the time lived in Paris) and Eugen Sahan, who in 1991 began publishing the
Documents of the Resistance (volumes 1-8), studied the archives of the AFDPR
and, together with other contributors - standing out among which were Dr Nicolau,
the priest Constantin Voicescu, Mircea Dumitrescu and Traian Popescu - collected
also other data from the oral memory of the former political detainees.
In January-March 1995, the group at the NIST drew up a research methodology
based on the idea of checking the data used with the help of crossed sources,
if possible, which should lead to the clarifications needed with a view to
introducing the former detainees in such a Dictionary. In other words, they
meant the Dictionary to coordinate the various sources by checking once more,
rounding off the data on the anti-ecclesiastical repression and making sure
those data were accurate.
Consequently, we conceived and submitted to the Cults, in March 1995, a nominal
table to be filled with the following: surname, name and monachal name, date
and place of birth, position in the hierarchy of the respective denomination,
place of service, year of arrest, reason, sentence and the time served in
prison, detention places, date and place of death or whether the person is
alive. Much later it was noticed that, immediately, on 21 March 1995, the
Chancellery of the Patriarchate -mentioning the NIST's address no. 722/1995
- accepted, based on approval from the Patriarch, to answer our request to
all the dioceses. Moreover, they reminded the dioceses that, under Resolution
no.2402/1991 of the Holy Synod of the Orthodox Church, they were asked to
draw up documentary tables to be forwarded to the Chancellery of the Holy
Synod. Thus we subsequently learned that duplicates had been received, of
which other researchers, too, had been appraised, whereas the NIST gained
access to such data quite late. Anyway, the NIST got its own replies from
most Orthodox dioceses, except the one of Tomis (Constanta) which refused
to cooperate although it was their region that harboured the camps of the
Canal, the resistance of the Babadag forest and of other places in Dobruja,
as well as the 90 priests recorded by the documentary literature (they were
forced to do hard labour until it killed them; according to some detainees,
that happened at Salcia, Balta Brailei while according to others, it happened
at Periprava or at Mamaia (?)...)
We though that the research had to acquire an ecumenical extent and we approached
all the official cults, reverting subsequently with a new request (the letters
of 10 Sep.1996, bearing the number 1857).
The requests put forth during talks with the representatives of the Romanian
Intelligence Service's Archives and of the State Secretariat for Cults, inl995-1996,
were not met. 653 mentions came from the dioceses. The data received are organized
in a manuscript file and in a databank created purposefully. Further on we
shall present the table with the sources that answered our requests, encoding
the answers correspondingly (either institutions or collaborators of the NIST).
In October 1995 we learned that the Archbishopric of Vad, Feleac and Cluj
was compiling a similar work. On the occasion of his visit at the NIST, the
Most Reverend Bartolomeu Anania confirmed the above and we appraised him of
the stage we were in, with the 1,269 persons recorded (1,180 Orthodox, 30
Roman-Catholic and 59 Greek-Catholic). We agreed to work together. Then His
Reverence, going to Cluj, studied with Deacon Stefan Iloaie the data concerning
each person. The result was a modest but consistent 86-page work published
in January 1996 under the title Confessors behind Bars. Servants of the Church
in the Communist Prisons, printed by the review of the Cluj Archbishopric,
Renasterea. A protocol on this cooperation between the representative of the
NIST and of the Archbishopric was concluded in Cluj, on 6 November 1995. The
complete variant taken to Cluj covered 1,321 persons who were checked by both
delegates, overlapping being eliminated. Corroboration of the different sources
attested that the information largely coincided, coming from persons and institutions
that had offered data to the NIST and to the Archbishopric. We were glad we
had fulfilled the moral duty of drawing up a first list of the ecclesiastical
personnel imprisoned for political reasons (hierarchs, priests, monks, professors,
theologians, theology students and readers from various parishes in the country),
whether they belonged to the Orthodox, Roman-Catholic or Greek-Catholic confession.
We had information that the Romanian Intelligence Service and the General
Directorate of Penitentiaries had "salvaged" the two computers the
First and Second Office of the CC of the RCP used for recording all the political
detainees. Therefore we insisted for a natural cooperation, but that was not
possible. That is why the NIST could survey only 20 penal files from the Military
Justice Directorate at the Ministry of Justice, an operation that took several
months. We found out from those files, for instance, that one Orthodox priest
appeared in the table conveyed by his diocese as having been imprisoned for
5 years, whereas he had actually served 18 years in jail. The file also contained
other names which we extracted. Those were but a few out of the thousands
of files that should have been studied. For this reason this Dictionary is
not fully satisfactory, the work having to be furthered by younger specialists
desirous to make public the sacrifices the Churches assumed in order to preserve
the faith in God and in the democratic values.
Under such constraints, we started work on a Dictionary including the necessary
specifications for each name of a Church servant, insofar as we had such data.
This being a field where misinformation is practiced, we sought not to personally
interpret the cases recorded, even if there were possible suspicions or undocumented
assertions. Consequently, we decided to specify in the Dictionary the sources
of any assertion, these sources being printed under the recorded item. Therefore
for each name, we provided elements of identity, biographical elements and
the nonconcordances in the documents surveyed.
In December 1995 we submitted the NIST's work, which included 1,321 names,
to His Beatitude Patriarch Teoctist (in the presence of Academician Virgil
Candea). The book later published jointly with the Archbishopric of Cluj comprises
1,653 names. The present Dictionary contains about 2,500 names and substantial
additions of a biographical and documentary nature. A recent estimate made
by author Cicerone Ionitoiu (Romania libera, 10 May 1997, p. 6) indicates
"about 4,000 imprisoned priests, including some who were sentenced two
or even three times, while others were sentenced for administrative charges.
Therefore 4,000 members of the clergy thrown in jail, over 250 of whom were
exterminated..."
We do not know whether the author took into account only the priests, as we
believe he did, unlike the present Dictionary, which surveys all the categories
of ecclesiastical personnel.
If many names are missing from the Dictionary, that is because
we did not receive all the answers we requested from all the official cults
(especially from the Protestant Church). The Neoprotestant cults were not
included in the Dictionary (except for the cases with the express mention
preacher or pastor) since we proposed not to include laymen who suffered for
the sake of their faith, their confessional hierarchy being uncertain. For
instance, Jehovah's Witnesses let us know that all their members were preachers
and that they did not have a hierarchy distinct from the administrative one.
The Mosaic religion sent us a list of 11 persons for whom the birth year was
not specified. The Archbishopric of Tomis and the one of Covasna and Harghita
failed to reply.
We resorted to researching the detention literature (memoirs, diaries) published
after 1989. About 170 works were read, many of which gave names of priests
(often without sufficient elements for identification - see the encoded list
of these books). Moreover, we studied church reviews issued after 1989, which
contained data of use to our research. Unfortunately, the collections at the
Orthodox Patriarchate or at the Catholic Archbishopric are neither complete
nor organized according to the rules of library science; that explains certain
incomplete datings in the Dictionary, in the case of source R (reviews).
For instance, I for one was unable to identify a priest, a hermit, who was
with me in November or December 1950 at Gherla, in a re-education room. Despite
all my efforts not even now have I been able to mention him properly. Also,
from February until October 1950, in secret room 5 at Jilava I had as a mate
a Roman-Catholic vicar of Oradea, who was Hungarian and a writer and was of
Cumanian origin and who was not recorded in the tables of the Roman-Catholic
Archbishopric. I found him two years later with help from Father Fodor from
Oradea. He had been badly beaten by the political police and he had had, just
like myself, his shoes torn from the beating with iron crowbars on the soles
of his feet. Moreover, I cannot recall a pastor considered a leader of the
Seventh-Day Adventist denomination; he was a vegetarian and in 1952 or 1953
we were imprisoned together at the Rahova headquarters of the political police
(Bucharest). I have never known his name. I am just fulfilling the duty of
mentioning all those who were not identified. People should not forget that
Father Vasile Tepordei from Cahul was tried by a Soviet Court in Constanta
and sent to the USSR, to the camps of the Soviet gulag (gulag is the Russian
and communist name of political detention penitentiaries and therefore it
does not suit the penitentiary space in Romania).
After the publication of Confessors behind Bars. Servants of the Church in
the Communist Prisons, I was told that the Most Reverend Nicolae Corneanu,
too, had been arrested by the political police. I wrote him and got an answer
from His Reverence (2 April 1996 and the answer no. 1618 from 9 April 1996)
asking us not to make "a big fuss over past things... representing a
personal matter..." He had been interrogated by Securitate chiefs Ambrus
and Mois from Timisoara. His Reverence was to do it later.
A useful degree paper is the one of the priest Gabriel Valeriu
Basa (Sibiu) who, besides the common data, also presented a list of 119 persons
including 67 detainees and 52 persons who had died in prison.
Our databank stores the lists of persons purged from the ecclesiastical institutions
over 1945-1948 who were not included in the volume; and also the list of church
personnel from Bessarabia who were deported to Romania during the 1940 Soviet
occupation, with the dioceses where they were sent (Victor Besliu), which
was not introduced in the volume in order to be subjected to a selection of
the persons later detained by the communist regime in Romania.
Both lists contain hundreds of names of people who suffered the disciplines
of this totalitarian regime. A similar list is being drawn up by the review
Memoria.
As is known, many names are mentioned in the books, articles or recorded memoirs
of the former political prisoners, direct witnesses of the communist repression
but, unfortunately, they are not accompanied by sufficient identification
elements. Therefore there are several instance of anonymous reference to priests
who could be given their due place in a subsequent edition. Likewise, the
study of the political police's files may also hold surprises related to the
darker aspects of these people who should have been spared the crudest suffering,
the one of losing their dignity following the inquiries of the Securitate
during the terrifying re-education or during detention. Let us not forget,
however, to wonder, in the first place and always, who unleashed the repression,
who needed to soil the human dignity and especially the dignity of those who
served the churches and the faith in God, with their heroism and their failures.
Let us not forget that revolutions presuppose, in their essence, the satanic
idea of "rebellion" and therefore, whatever the way they presented
or concealed their "intellectual," "social" or "moral"
goals, they meant from the very beginning to deal blows to the Church, the
one of Christ in particular, even when it made proof of dogmatic intransigence
or tolerance understood as a foible of the love for one's fellow beings.
Fernand Lafargue, a member of the Club de l'Horloge, says: "Socialism
therefore appears today as the spearhead of this rebellion against God and
against the «status quo» and we see better why, in all the countries
of the socialist bloc, the foremost concern of the power has been to eradicate
any religion, and especially the Christian religion (...) religious persecution
is not accidental, but fundamental, determining and sanctioning the ((revolutionary
rebuilding of the status quo». "
This explains, in broad lines, the unparalleled repression enforced by the
communist-totalitarian revolutions. Can the number of the Inquisition's victims,
approx. 30 thousand dead, compare with the 40 thousand priests during the
Leninist period and another 5,000 under Stalin? With the number of priests
victimized by the Spanish revolution or during the French revolution? Or with
the aggregate number of priests assassinated between 1917 and 1980, 200 thousand
persons plus the 500 thousand who were imprisoned or deported (Iakovlev's
report, 1995)?
In communist Romania, the "atheist revolution" certainly did not
reach such a paroxysmal point, although I would consider comparing the crimes
as cynical were this not meant to illustrate a study on the repression the
ecclesiastical world was subjected to. Still we found it very difficult to
assess the ones who should have been (and are) recorded in the hand-written,
typed or computerized databases of archives. But how can one evaluate the
ones who were reported missing (even after they had been released), the ones
shot during the actions of the anticommunist resistance in the mountains or
as supporters, the ones who were deported, purged or sent into retirement
for no reason other that they had not manifested their support for the communist
regime, or those who died in doubtful circumstances. And that, beyond the
faked reasons or motives elicited under duress. The charges were: political
activity, espionage, sabotage, sedition, secret catechization, aiding the
fugitives or their families. The memoirs of the former detainees often contain
simple names, with no additional data. For instance, in his Camp Paper, Caracal,
1945, Onisifor Ghibu mentions a great many priests but the work also contains
such mentions as "Father Mihale" at p. 103, "the monk Eftimie
from the Hermitage in Neamt" at p. 96 and so on. From the same book it
emerges that in 1945, when the camp at Caracal was set up, about 90 priests
were interned there (mostly Orthodox but also of other confessions).
I know a brilliant doctor, the son of a priest, who would not have had any
chance to go to university and was therefore adopted by a miner (an inspired
one) until he finished medical school. And there were many others in this
situation, even if they had not been born to a priest's family. I must mention
here the four hermits from the Cetatuia Hermitage at Campulung who in August
1947 had taken us in; the "nameless" priest who gave us shelter
in his home at the Patriarchate, after the arrests of 15 May 1948; or the
vicar who lived in Mihai Bravu Street, again in June 1948; or the vicar at
the Delea Veche Church in Bucharest: the "resistant" priests at
the Antim Monastery and in the Rugul Aprins (The Burning Bush) group.
We should pay a pious homage also to the former young and mature political
detainees who, after their release from prison, took holy orders or became
monks: Lucian Avramescu, Pavel Tegzcs, Nicu (Nicolae) Patrascu.
COSMOVICI, HORIA; b. 1909 at Tureatca (?): Greek-Catholic
priest. An apprentice of Monsignor Ghika; arrested six times, the last time
in 1948 when he was sentenced to 25 years of hard labour: places of detention:
Jilava, Aiud, Periprava, Ocnele Mari, Gherla, Margineni; freed after he was
granted a pardon in 1964.
MARACINE, PAUL; b. 03.03.1928 Bucharest; Orthodox priest. Served at the St. Vasile Church in Bucharest; arrested between 25.05.1949 and 24.04.1956; detention place: Aiud.
STEINHARDT, NICOLAE; m.n. NICOLAE OF ROHIA; b. 12.07.1912, com. Pantelimon, Bucharest; d. 29.03.1989; Orthodox monk. Intellectual Jew converted to Christianity; Graduated from the faculties of Law and Letters and Philosophy in Bucharest; doctor of constitutional law; arrested on 04.01.1960 with the batch of "Intellectuals" (C. Noica, Al. Paleologu, V. Voiculescu, a/o.); sentenced on 05.03.1960 to 13 years in jail; detention places: Malmaison, Jilava (where on 15.03.1960 he converted to Orthodoxy, being baptized by Father Mina Dobzeu), Gherla; released in August 1964; on 16.08.1980 he became a monk at the Rohia Monastery, Cluj county; he died en route to Bucharest.
VOICESCU, CONSTANTIN; b. 05.08.1924 m Bucharest; d. 08.10.1997; Orthodox priest. Served at the Bucharest Theological Institute; arrested in 1949; reason; sedition; sentenced by the Bucharest Military Court, under sentence no. 538/1949, to 4 years in prison; detention place: Jilava; arrested again in 1958 under the same charges; sentenced by the Bucharest Military Court, under sentence no. 844/1959, to forced labour for life; detention place: Aiud. Nc. Geography undergraduate in 1949; Between 1950 and 1954 imprisoned at Tg. Ocna.
The list will certainly include many more than we could identify.
In Russia, immediately after the 1917 revolution, repression
was unleashed against the Church (the church and state separated and atheism
was declared the main ideological support). In 192214 the Bolshevik state
embarked on seizing the huge wealth of the church and punishing the priests
for their resistance. Thus, in that year, the communists executed over 8000
servants of the Church, at head with Metropolitan Beniamin; also they commissioned
the first anti-religious publishing house and organized the first wide-scope
carnivals designed to ridicule the Christian rituals.
In Romania, the action of officializing the camps for political detainees
began as early as 1944 in each county. Thus there were camps at Slobozia Veche,
Ciurel-Bucharest, Timisul de Sus - for monks, Timisul de Jos - for nuns, Lugoj,
Pitesti and Vulcan for members of the Iron Guard (in February 1945 there were
as many as 4600 inmates at Targu Jiu), with a total of approx. 10,200 detainees15.
In fact at that time there were 36 numbered camps and much more detainees.
Even Radio London commented (21 Nov. 1944) that Romania "failed to comply
satisfactorily with the terms of the armistice".
Interesting information can be found in Gheorghe Onisoru's article The Middle
Class and the Road to Socialism (about the purges in the state administration,
the black lists, etc.)16. Actually, several relevant studies were written
by N. Hurjui, G. Dragulin, S. Stolojan, I. Ploscaru, and M. Berindei a/o.
The older camps were overcrowded with political prisoners (Targu Jiu was one
such case). At the same time, commissions were created to draw up lists of
Iron Guardists (including priests) and of ethnic Germans and Hungarians, purges
were initiated and the political police made arrests (ca.8293 in- 1944) and
instituted surveillance (measures ordered by Soviet General Vinogradov). Moreover,
there was a tidal wave of exposures and adliesions to the new regime, determined
by the fear of deportation and imprisonment, concurrently with the start of
the anticommunist resistance.
Although on 27 Sep. 1945 the Council of Ministers had decided to close the
camps, subsequently they were reorganized. A piece of information that we
could not check indicates that a batch of 140 priests from Timisoara was detained
at the Ocnele Mari prison. After the 1947 Council of Orthodox Patriarchs (Metropolitans),
held in Moscow and attended by delegates from the socialist countries, an
"Appeal" was launched, urging "antifascist struggle and struggle
against the Vatican." Patriarch Nicodim withdrew at the Neamt Monastery.
The Church was affected by Decree no. 166 of 1947 on the "deposition"
of 17 Orthodox hierarchs - metropolitans and bishops or vicars - listed below.
The List of Deposed Orthodox Metropolitans
CRIVEANU, GRIGORIE; m.n. NIFON; b. 20.02.1889 at Slatioara, Olt County; d. 14.06.1970 in Bucharest; Orthodox metropolitan bishop. Studies at the Central Seminary (1902-1910) and at the Faculty of Theology of Montpellier and Paris (1924-1928); a priest at Lucaci church (1916-1922) and Popa Soare church (1922-1924) in Bucharest; professor and director at the "Nifon" Seminary of Bucharest (1924-1928); became a monk at the Cernica Monastery, under the name Nifon; Archimandrite in 1928; Arch-dean at the Ramnicului Bishopric, with the title "Craioveanul" (1929-1933); elected Bishop of Husi on 19.10.1933 and Metropolitan Bishop of Oltenia on 30.11.1939; forced to retire on 20.04.1945 (aged fifty-six).
ENACHESCU, IOAN; m.n. EFREM; b. 21.05.1893 Zavoieni, com. Maciuca, Valcea County; d. 05.12.1968 at the Cernica Monastery; metropolitan. In 1908 he enters the Frasinei Monastery as a brother; in 1910 he becomes a monk, by the name of Efrem, at the Stanisoara Monastery and then he moves to Cozia Monastery where he is ordained a deacon monk and priest monk; after graduation from the Central seminary in Bucharest (1912-1920), he serves at the St. Nicolae Seminary in Ramnicu Valcea (1921-1923); superior of the Cozia Monastery (1922-1928); director of the Church Readers School at Cozia (1925-1928); ordained an archimandrite in 1923; he attends the Faculty of Theology in Bucharest (1923-1928) and specialized courses at Montpellier, France (1928-1930); a professor and director of the Seminary in Ramnicu Valcea (1930-1933) and exarch of the monasteries belonging to the Bishopric of Ramnic (1930-1936), then a priest at the patriarchal cathedral and exarch of the monasteries in the Archbishopric of Bucharest (1936-1938); in February 1938 he is elected a vicar bishop with the title of Tighineanul and is appointed an archbishop's deputy at Chisinau (1938-1943); on 12.01.1944 he is elected Archbishop of Chisinau and Metropolitan of Bessarabia but a few months later he is forced to seek refuge; he serves as a confessor at the boarding house of the theological seminary in Bucharest (1947-1948) and superior of the Cernica Monastery until his retirement in 1952. Nc. Rounded up from Cernica; died in prison.
LAZARESCU, VASILE; b. 01.01.1894 Comesti, Timis County; d. 21.02.1969; metropolitan. After graduation from high school in Timisoara and from the Faculty of Theology in Cernauti, and after the doctor's degree obtained in 1919, he took courses of pedagogy and philosophy at the Universities of Bucharest and Vienna; he taught dogmatics, apologetics and morals at the Theological Institute in Sibiu (1920-1924) and at the Theological Academy in Oradea (1924-1933); an editor for the diocesan journal Legea Romaneasca issued in Oradea (1925-1931); he became a monk in 1928; ordained archimandrite (1929); elected bishop of Caransebes on 21.10.1933; consecrated as bishop on 21.12.1933; enthroned on 15.04.1934; elected bishop of Timisoara on 12.06.1940; enthroned on 25.03.1941; in 1947 he became Archbishop of Timisoara and Metropolitan of Banat; upon the request of the communist authorities, he was sent into retirement on 18.12.1961 at the Cernica Monastery, which is also where de died; the reason for his forced retirement was that he had helped the families of some imprisoned priests; he was buried in the Cathedral in Timisoara. As a hierarch, he insisted for the reopening of certain monasteries in Banat (Saraca, Partos, Sf. Hie de la Izvor, Lipova, Cebza), he supervised the building of the Cathedral in Timisoara (consecrated on 06.10.1946), the activity of the Theological Academies in Caransebes and Oradea (the latter sought refuge in Timisoara after 30.08.1940), as well as the diocesan bulletins Foaia Diocezana (Caransebes), Biserica Banateana (Timisoara) and the reviews Duh si Adevar, Mitropolia Banatului, Calendarul Eparhial etc.
LEU, GHEORGHE; m.n. GRIGORIE; b. 02.05.1881 in Tutcani com., Vaslui County; d. 01.03.1949; bishop. After graduating from the Secondary Seminary in Roman and from the Superior Seminary in Iasi (1897-1901), he was ordained priest for Oancea parish, Galati County, where he served between 1904 and 1910, during which time he also attended the courses of the Faculty of Theology in Bucharest (1906-1910); took his diploma in Theology, installed confessor at the Central Seminary in Bucharest (1910-1916), then as army priest (1916-1918), director of the Seminar}' in Ismail (1918-1924); in 1924, a widower already, installed bishop-vicar of the Archbishopric of Iasi, with the title of "Botosaneanul"; on 30.04.1936 installed bishop of Arges (07.06.1936); installed bishop of Husi on 11.06.1940 (18.07.1940); served in Husi until 05.02.1949, when the Communist authorities forced him to retire; in order to find reasons to make him retire, the authorities invalidated his eparchy, living him without an office (The Eparchy of Husi was united to the Bishopric of Roman, into one eparchy, as the Bishopric of Roman and Husi; he had to take residence at Sf. Apostoli Petra si Pavel monastery in Husi (former cathedral and residence of the Bishopric of Husi, now turned into a monastery), where he died (allegedly poisoned), after a heart-attack brought about by his grief, to which added his worry about his son, priest Vasile Leu, detained in Communist prisons. "Left without an eparchy, because of the new administrative canonic organization of the Romanian Orthodox Church, he asked to be dismissed and given his retirement rights; taking into account the recommendations of the Sf. Sinod appeal, Grigore Leu took residence at the Sf. Apostoli Petru si Pavel monastery to be set in Husi, of the former Bishopric Cathedral, including the buildings and the households around. The director of the authorities within the ministry pledged to fulfill the regulations of this decision."; at Jilava: "Doctor Voiculescu and Bishop Leu (weakened, walking in crutches, dressed up in shepherd's clothes) are thoroughly interrogated by the guards, who are probably very bored. They are both humiliated and scorned at, insulted, cursed and defiled."
MIHALCESCU, IOAN; m.n. IRINEU; b. 24.04.1874 com. Valea Viei, Buzau County; d. 03.04.1948; metropolitan. After secondary school in Buzau (1887-1889), the Buzau Seminary (1889-1891), he attended the Faculty of Theology and Philosophy in Berlin and Leipzig (1901-1904) and took a Ph.D. in philosophy in Leipzig (13.06.1903); he served as: an assistant professor of Greek at the Central Seminary (1894-1900), secretary of the Theological Boarding School in Bucharest (1900-1901), agrege (1904) and professor (1908) at the Chair of Dogmatic and Symbolic Theology of the Bucharest Faculty of Theology (until 1939); dean of the Bucharest Faculty of Theology (1927-1929 and 1933-1936); dean of the Faculty of Theology in Chisinau (1926-1927); priest starting 1923; vicar bishop of the Bucharest Archbishopric having the title of Targovisteanul (1936); deputy bishop of Ramnic with the title Craioveanul (1938-1939); deputy Metropolitan of Oltenia (1939) and Metropolitan of Moldavia (elected on 29.11.1939 and enthroned on 17.12.1939); he shepherded until 16.08.1947, when he retired from his office; exile at the Neamt Monastery; exterminated in 1948 in unclear circumstances, his death occurring on 03.04.1948 at the Agapia Monastery; he published valuable studies of dogmatics, apologetics, the history of religions, as well as translations, being considered his time's greatest Romanian theologian; he participated in anticommunist meetings abroad, where he made Orthodoxy known in the Catholic and Protestant milieus of the West.
PUIU, VICTOR: m.n. VISARION; b. 27.02.1879 Pascani, Iasi County; d. 10.08.1964 in Paris; metropolitan. Studies at the Seminaries in Roman (1893-1896) and Veniamin in Iasi (1896-1900), at the Faculty of Theology in Bucharest (1900-1904) and at the Clerical Academy in Kiev (1907-1908); tonsured into monasticism in Roman (1905) and ordained a deacon monk for the Episcopal Cathedral in Roman (1905-1908); ordained as priest monk and archimandrite (1909) and appointed administrative vicar of the Lower Danube Bishopric and director of the St. Andrei Seminary in Galati (1909-1918), then director of the Seminary in Chisinau (1908) and exarch of the monasteries in Bessarabia (1918); he served as Bishop of Arges (17.03.1921-1923), Hotin, with his seat at Balti (1923-1935), Metropolitan of Bukovina (1935-1940) and of Trans-Dniester, with his seat in Odessa (1942-1943); in July 1944 he left for Zagreb as Patriarch Nicodim's envoy , to attend the ordaining of a bishop for the Croatian Orthodox Church; after 23.08.1944, as he could not return to Romania, he sought refuge in the West (Austria, Italy, Switzerland, and from September 1949 in France); on 21.02.1946 a People's Court sentenced him to death in absentia; under pressure from the communist authorities, the Holy Synod unfrocked him on 28.02.1950; rehabilitated on 25.09.1990; after 1949 he set up in France an Orthodox Bishopric with its seat at the Romanian Church in Paris; he headed this diocese until 1958 when he retired at Viels-Maison, near Chateau-Thierry, Aisne, where he died on 10.08.1964.
SIMEDREA, TEODOR; m.n. TIT; b. 04.09.1886 com. Naipu, Giurgiu County; d. 09.12.1971 Cernica; metropolitan. Studies at the Nifon Seminary, at the Bucharest Faculty of Theology and at the Faculty of Law in Iasi, with further studies in Montpellier and Paris; priest at the Prunaru parish, Teleonnan County, then at Blejesti, Vlasca County and at Movila Peris, Ilfov County (1907-1916); military confessor (1916-1920); priest at the St. Nicolae Tabacu Church in Bucharest (1921-1923); director of the Holy Synod's Chancellery and minister at the Metropolitan Cathedral in Bucharest (1923-1925); he became a monk at Cernica, in 1924, his monachal name being Tit and he was elected vicar bishop of the Bucharest Archbishopric, with the title Targovisteanul (1926-1935); director of the Biblical Institute's Printing House; director and professor of liturgies at the Religious Music Academy; editorial secretary with the review Biserica Ortodoxa Romana: participant in several conferences abroad: Lausanne (1927), Sofia (1929), Constantinople (1929), Vatoped (1930); on 11.1-2.1935 he was elected Bishop of Hotin, with his seat at Balti, and on 13.06.1940 he was elected Metropolitan of Bukovina with headquarters in Cernauti (enthroned on 25.03.1941); he retired from office on 31.06.1945, as he expected to be deposed; as a retiree he was sent to the Darvari Hermitage in Bucharest, and in 1959 to Cernica; he published valuable works on the Romanian culture, including as editor, on the beginnings of monasticism in this country, and many theology studies and articles, speeches, pastorals, reviews, notes; he died on 09.12.1971 at Cemica.
The List of Deposed Orthodox Bishops and Vicars
ANTAL, DUMITRU; m.n. EMILIAN; b. 20.10.1894 Toplita, Harghita County; d. 15.06.1971; vicar bishop. Studies at high schools in Brasov and Nasaud (1905-1913) and then at the Theological Institute in Sibiu (1913-1916) and at the Philosophy Department of the Budapest University (1916-1918); deacon at the Metropolitan cathedral in Sibiu (1921-1924); priest and archpriest at Reghin (1924-1927); diocesan inspector in Cluj (1927-1933); priest at the Bradu Boteanu Church in Bucharest (1933-1938) and general inspector in the Ministry of Cults (1935-1938); tonsured as a monk at the Dragomirna Monastery, as Emilian, and consecrated as archimandrite (1938); elected vicar bishop at the Patriarchate, with the title Targovisteanul, on 28.10.1938 and consecrated on 06.12.1938; delegated to head the Arges Bishopric, as deputy bishop (1941-1944), and then the ecclesiastical province of Bukovina which in 1947 became the Archbishopric of Suceava (Feb. 1945-Sep. 1948); after 1948 he was removed from this office and appointed professor at the Theological Seminary at the Neamt Monastery (1949-1950), superior at the Cozia Monastery and at the Toplita Monastery in Harghita County, where he died on 15.06.1971; he published various studies and articles in Telegrafid Roman and Revista Teologica of Sibiu, in Renasterea in Cluj and in Buletinul Eparhiei Argesului.
CIOPRON, PETRU; m.n. PARTENIE; b. 30.09.1986 com. Paltinis, Botosani County; d. 28.07.1980; bishop. After graduation from the Church Readers School in Iasi, he was called up for military service; he fought in World War I and was wounded at Oituz; at the end of the war he became a monk at Slatina Monastery, his monachal name being Partenie; he attended the Veniamin Costache Seminary in Iasi (1922-1929) and the Faculty of Theology in Cernauti (1929-1933), where he took his doctor's degree in 1935; while he studied he was a deacon monk and priest monk at the Metropolitan Cathedral in Iasi and after graduation he was an archimandrite, exarch of the monasteries within the Archbishopric of Iasi and he taught religion in Iasi; on 17.06.1937 he was appointed bishop with the Army, with his seat in Alba Iulia, and he served in this capacity until 1948; between 1941 and 1944 he was a deputy bishop at Balti (Bessarabia); after 1948, when the Bishopric of the Army was dissolved, he was left without a diocese and served as a teacher and director of the Monachal Seminary at the Neamt Monastery (1948-1950) and as a superior of the St. loan eel Nou Monastery of Suceava (1950-1961); in December 1961 he was appointed a deputy bishop of Roman and Husi, and on 18.02.1962 he was elected bishop of that diocese, where he functioned until 01.01.1978 when, falling ill, he retired at the Varatec Monastery, where he later died; he published studies and articles in the paper Viata Monahala of Iasi, which was issued with his support, and in Anna Cuvantului, the review of the Army Bishopric.
DINCA, ALEXANDRU; m.n. ATANASIE; b. 22.12.1896 in com. Cernica, Ilfov County; d. 06.01.1973; Orthodox archbishop-dean. Graduated the School for church cantors of Bucharest (1911-1914); a cantor at Olari and Sf. Vineri churches in Bucharest; became a monk at Tismana Monastery (1915); further studies at the "Nifon" Seminary and the Faculty of Theology of Bucharest, graduating in 1934; while a student, serves as : deacon at the Ramnic Bishopric (1915-1916), military father confessor at the hospital in Iasi (1916-1918), priest at Campurelu, Giurgiu County and Artari, Ialomita County (1918-1923), priest at the Episcopal Cathedral of Constanta (1923-1924), father confessor at the "Nifon" Seminary, teacher at the School for Church Cantors of Bucharest (1924-1928), exarch of the monasteries in Constanta County, teacher and director of the School for Church Cantors of Constanta (1928-1931), Father Superior of the Ghighiu and Caldarusani Monasteries, exarch of the monasteries of the Bucharest Archbishopric (1931-1943); on 01.11.1943, elected Patriarchal Archbishop-Dean, with the title "Barladeanul"; between 21.04.1945-11.03.1948, acting bishop of the Ramnic Bishopric; after 01.04.1948, dismissed from this office and appointed for a few years Father Superior to Domnita Balasa church in Bucharest, and church music professor at the Monachal Seminary of Neamt Monastery; retired in 1956 to Caldarusani Monastery for the rest of his life.
MOGLAN, [...]; m.n. VALERIE; b. 17.05.1878, Calugareni, Neamt county; Vicar-Bishop of the Bishopric of Moldavia and Suceava. He went to elementary school and junior high-school in Piatra Neamt; after his military service he became a monk at the Neamt Monastery on 16. 05. 1902, then he was ordained hierodeacon on 19.01.1903 and hieromonach on 25.03.1904, then he was called by the Metropolitan Bishopric and served there in various positions; under Metropolitan Bishop Pimen he was elected Father Superior of the Neamt Monastery; after 1912 he left for Russia, where he studied theology at Kazan and Moscow; he came back and his studies were recognized by the University of Cernauti. He returned to Neamt as Father Superior and, shortly afterwards he left for France, then for Canada; he returned in 1927 as Father Superior of the Neamt Monastery; on 15.06.1936 he was appointed vicar and in 1938 he was promoted to the rank of Vicar-Bishop and oecumen of the St. Spiridon church; when the totalitarian regime was established in Romania, the Vicar-Bishop Moglan was dismissed and sent into retirement to the monastery; he died on 13. 08. 1949, and buried in the cemetery of St. loan Bogoslov at the Neamt Monastery.
MORUSCA, POMPEI; m.n. POLICARP; b. 20.03.1883 Cristesti-Dealul Geoagiului, Alba County; d. 26.10.1958 Alba Iulia; bishop. Having graduated from high school in Alba Iulia and Blaj, he enrolled at the Theological Institute in Sibiu (1902-1905); he served as a teacher at confessional primary schools at Sebes-Alba, Ludos-Sibiu and Paclisa-Alba (1905-1908), as priest at Seica-Mare, Sibiu County (1908-1919), military confessor (1917-1918), adviser at the Diocesan Centre of Cluj (1919-1920), confessor at the Theological Institute in Sibiu (1920-1921) and editor with the Theological Review of Sibiu (1921-1922); in 1925 he was tonsured , received the name of Policarp and was appointed superior of the Hodos-Bodrog Monastery (1925-1935); in 1926 he was consecrated as archimandrite; on 24.01.1935 he was elected bishop for the Romanians in America (ordained as bishop on 24.03.1935 and enthroned in Detroit on 04.07.1935); he organized the diocese (with 6 deaneries, 44 parishes, 62 chapters, 43 churches and 34 priests); he started publication of the diocesan gazette Solia and of the Calendarul eparhial Solia, which have been published up to this day; he laid the foundations of the Vatra Romaneasca diocesan centre, attached to which were a farm, a retirement home and a monastery; in 1939 he returned to Romania to attend the meetings of the Holy Synod; he could not go back to his diocese in America; up to 1948 he served as: deputy bishop of Cetatea Alba-Ismail, Bessarabia (1941-1944), director of the Theological Institute in Bucharest (1944-1945) and as deputy bishop of Maramures, with his seat at Sighet (1945-1946); in 1948 he retired and withdrew at the St. loan Botezatorul Monastery in Alba Iulia, the superior of which he was between 1955 and 1958; "The head of the Romanian Orthodox Diocese of America and the Western States; he is removed from the position he holds as of the date of publication of the present decree in M.O."
PETROVICI, COSMA; b. 11.01.1873 Braila; d. 16.12.1948 Galati; bishop. Graduated from the Theological Seminary of Galati (1888-1892) and of Iasi (1892-1896); attended the Faculty of Theology m Cernauti (1896-1900); deacon (1897); priest and archpriest at Dorohoi (1902-1913); he taught religion at the school of Pomarla (1913-1917); having been widowed, in 1923 he was elected a vicar bishop at the Iasi Archbishopric, receiving the title of Botoseneanul, and on 25.06.1924 he was elected bishop of the Lower Danube (enthroned on 19.07.1924); he was deposed in August 1947 and forced to go into retirement.
POPOVICIU, NICOLAE; b. 29.01.1903 Biertan-Sibiu; d. 20.10.1960 Biertan; bishop. High school at Dumbraveni; normal school in Sibiu, with validation exam and graduation diploma from the Andrei Saguna High School in Brasov (1923); the Theological Academy of Sibiu (1923-1927), with validation exam at the Faculty of Theology in Cernauti, which also grants him his doctor's degree in 1934; specialization at the Divinity School in Athens (1927-1928) and at the Faculties of Philosophy of Munich (1928-1930), Tubingen, Leipzig and Breslau (1930-1932); a professor of dogmatics and apologetics at the Theological Academy in Sibiu (1932-1936); deacon (1929) and priest (1934); elected Bishop of Oradea on 26.04.1936; between 1940 and 1944 he found refuge at Beius; forced to retire on 05.10.1950; house arrest at the Cheia Monastery until 1960; he died on 20.10.1960, at Biertan (where his family had brought him, seriously ill, from the Cheia Monastery); re-interred on 23.08.1992 in the cathedral of Oradea.
SCOROBET, TRANDAFIR; m.n. TEODOR; b. 14.01.1883 Streza Cartisoara -Fagaras; d. 25.03.1967 Sibiu; vicar bishop. He graduated from the High School of Sibiu and from the Andrei Saguna High School in Brasov, from the Theological Institute in Sibiu (1902-1905); training courses as a teacher of Romanian and English at the University of Cluj (1919); elementary school teacher at Rasinari, Sibiu County (1905-1906); priest at the Romanian parishes in America (1906-1909) and at the parish of Rosia-Sibiu (1909-1919); he was imprisoned by the Hungarian authorities in Cluj, Oradea and Zambor between 1916 and 1918; archpriest (1922); teacher of Romanian and English at the Gheorghe Lazar High School in Sibiu (1920-1922); adviser at the Archbishopric of Sibiu (1922-1941); he became a monk in 1940 and was appointed administrative vicar of Sibiu in 1941, then he was elected vicar bishop of the Archbishopric of Sibiu, bearing the title of Rasinareanul (1946); he published studies and articles in church magazines; forced to retire in 1948; he died in Sibiu.
SERPE, PAVEL; b. 18.04.1897 com. Pastraveni, village of Radeni, Neamt County; vicar bishop. He attended the Veniamin Seminary in Iasi (1911-1920), the Faculty of Theology of Cernauti (1920-1924) and the Educational University Seminary of Bucharest (1925); ordained deacon in 1925 for the Episcopal cathedral in Constanta; he served as deacon also at the Sf. Apostoli Church and as a confessor at the Theological Seminary in Constanta (1925-1927); ordained priest in 1927; he served as a missionary at the Belvedere parish in the capital-city (until 1947) and as adviser at the Archbishopric of Bucharest (1945-1947); tonsured at the Neamt Monastery on 22.07.1947; consecrated as archimandrite on 23.07.1947; elected vicar bishop of the Bucharest Archbishopric, being given the title of Ploiesteanul, on 02.07.1947; ordained bishop on 31.08.1947; after 1948 he was forced to retire at the Curtea de Arges Monastery where for several years he was the superior and where he died on 18.04.1978; buried in the crypt in the basement of the Belvedere Church in the capital-city, where he had served for two decades as a missionary priest.
TRITEANU, LAZAR; m.n. LUCIAN; b. 15.08.1872 Feldioara-Razboieni, Alba County; bishop. Having finished high school in Blaj and Sibiu (1895), he attended the Theological Institute in Sibiu (1895-1898) and the Faculty of Philosophy of the Budapest university (1898-1901); school adviser (1901-1910) and adviser to the Archbishopric of Sibiu (1910-1923); ordained deacon and priest in 1910: he struggled in defense of the Romanian confessional schools in Transylvania, against the attempts to Hungarianize them; in autumn 1922 he was elected vicar bishop of the Bishopric of Ramnic, with the title Craioveanul; in January 1923 he was tonsured into monasticism as Lucian, but on 29.03.1923 the Holy Synod elected him Bishop of Roman (consecrated on 6 May and enthroned on 10.06.1923); he held that position until August 1947 when the authorities sent him into retirement; he died on 06.09.1953 in Roman.
Here is a list of Orthodox priests who took part in the struggles waged in the mountains against the political police: Nicolae Andreescu, Ion Constantinescu, Ion David, Ion Dragoi, Apostol Dumitru, Ion Jaflea, Evghenie Hulea, Dumitru Mihailescu.
Participants in armed actions and peasant resistance: Ion Colita, Hederegiu, Vasile Stoian, Gheorghe Ungurelu.
Priests who died in prison or during investigations: Gh.
Serban - com. Corlan, Constanta, shot dead on Easter Day in 1952 at Baia Sprie;
Puiu Dumitrescu-Lopatari; Soceanu of Ploiesti; Petre Focseneanu, again from
Ploiesti.
It is estimated that ca. 250 Orthodox priests died in prison and in battles
(Source Ionitoiu).
As far as the Most Reverend Nicolae Corneanu is concerned, according to what
he stated publicly (Romania lihera of 10.03.1997, p. 11), he had been involved
in the unfrocking of the following priests: Avramescu, George Dumitrescu Viorel,
Emil Ambnis Cernat, Liviu Negoita and Ionel Vinchici, whom he asked for forgiveness;
these priests officially sided with the priest Dumitreasa-Calciu, with the
Greek-Catholic Church and the "Oastea Domnului" (The Army of the
Lord); under pressure from the political police, some of them were put on
trial or expelled.
In July 1947, a report of the Romanian counterespionage showed that priests
of the various denominations who had fled abroad or stayed in the country
participated in . the Romanian Resistance Movement. The following are mentioned:
in Paris -parish priest Vasile Boldeanu, with articles in La Roumanie Independante,
which was subsidized by diplomats who had chosen to remain abroad and which
was "headed by the priests Neamtu Martin, Ogreanu, Teofil Ionescu, a/o;"
in Italy "there is an Orthodox group including several devotees of Maniu
like: (...) priest Tautu, Puiu Cucu, Ion Pop and other priests;" in Rome,
Metropolitan Visarion Puiu; in Germany the priest Branzeu; in the US the priests
Truta, Oprean and Moldovan, Ion Spataru, Gh. Anagnostache who contributed
to various magazines such as Liimina and Solia; the head of the Orthodox Church
in Paris, archimandrite Teofil Ionescu (Cartea alba a securitatii, 23 august
1944 - 30 august 1948, volume I, the Romanian Intelligence Service, 1997,
pp.378-381). In the US it was Bishop Valerian Trifa who was deposed and died
in exile in Portugal.
Mention should be made also of the Memorandum of the Romanian Uniate Bishops
of 29 March 1948 related to the draft Constitution (ibidem, pp.440-444).
The Uniate (Greek-Catholic) Church was severely affected - banned in fact
-by the law of 01.11.1948, as well as by the decrees on the closing of confessional
schools, the retirement of hierarchs (Decree no. 166/1947 on deposing the
bishops, the one of 31.03.1948 and Decree no.1777/1948 on restricting the
monastic and missionary activity, complemented by Decree no. 410 of December
1948 and by the law on the general regime of religious cults).
Moreover, the Roman-Catholic Church was left with 2 bishops out of 8 and its
activities were drastically limited (a unilateral breach of the Concordat
with the Vatican), which forced it to make certain compromises.
As Bishop loan Ploscaru shows, at Sighet alone were imprisoned 9 Greek-Catholic
bishops and a metropolitan, 3 Roman-Catholic bishops. 5 Catholic priests and
25 Greek-Catholic ones. Four Uniate priests from Lugoj were detained at the
Canal camp. Many of them died or were held in isolation at monasteries specially
set aside for this purpose.
Other authors (Serban Milcoveanu or C. Ionitoiu) state that between 1000 and
1400 Greek-Catholic and Roman-Catholic hierarchs and priests were arrested
and many were killed.
The first form at our disposal and even the final form of
Confessors behind Bars. Servants of the Church in the Communist Prisons recorded
a number of about 45 Roman-Catholics and 60 Greek-Catholics.
The text of State Decree no. 410 (which complemented the one of 04.08.1948),
reproduced here below, provides an image of who actually decided on the fate
of denominations and monasticism:
The Presidium of the Grand National Assembly of the People's Republic of Romania
decrees:
Art. 1 - Decree 177 of 4 August 1948, on the general regime of religious cults
is altered as follows:
After art. 7 comes art. 71 with the following content:
Art. 71 -Monasticism can function only in the authorized monasteries of the
legally recognized cults. Functioning authorization for monasteries is issued
by the Department of Cults.
Graduates from the schools training clergy can go into monasticism at any
age, provided they fulfilled military service.
Other persons can be admitted into monasticism only if they have reached the
age of 55 for men and 50 for women, if they give up the salary or the State
pension, if they are single and if they do not have obligations already established
by the Family Code.
In cases when the exercise of the religion requires it, the Department of
Cults will authorize certain monks to hold church positions and to receive
due salary.
The above provisions apply to existing monasteries and hermitages.
The Chairman of the Presidium of the
Grand National Assembly
I.Gh. Maurer
The Secretary of the Presidium of
the Grand National Assembly
Gh. Stoica
(Bucharest, 28 October 1959, no. 410)
In fact, as the documents in the White Book of the Political Police attest, the Politburo of the RCP was directly in charge of the "religious police", through the one entrusted with this matter, Vasile Luca. Instances of imprisonment, of repression of the religious freedoms, and destruction of the church heritage further occurred until 1989 (though imprisonment was resorted to less frequently) but the demolition of church monuments assumed a wider scope, the communist authorities ignoring any insistence of the religious and intellectual community. The priest Calciu-Dumitreasa paid with hard years in jail for his opposition to the demolition of Enei Church.
25 March 1949
Minutes of the working meeting of the Ministry of Internal Affairs
leadership establishing the tasks of the Securitate in the Catholic matter
In attendance were comrade minister Teohari Georgescu, comrade It.-gen. Pintilie Gheorghe, director general of the People's_Securitate comrade major general Nicolschi Alexandru and comrade major general Mazuru Vladimir, both of them deputy directors at the General Directorate of the People'sSecuritate; The agenda included the following problems:
1.Defining the position versus the Catholic problem in general;
2. The Catholic problem in Moldavia;
3. Defining the position on the question of monasteries.
Following the analysis made by minister Teohari Georgescu, it emerged that
the Catholic problem becomes more acute with every passing day, because of
the policy conducted by Catholic priests and monks belonging to various orders,
who are agents of the Pope and of the Anglo-American imperialism. Moreover,
the conclusion was reached that monasteries were a hotbed breeding plots,
sedition and instigation against the popular democracy regime.
After debates, the collective found the following measures were necessary:
1.Monks and nuns shall not be allowed to walk around in the rural environment,
that is, missionarism should be banned in tillages and towns;
2.Priests shall not be issued authorizations to collect money for the building
of churches or for other purposes;
3. Measures shall be taken against Roman-Catholic monasteries: monasteries
shall be closed down; the nuns and monks shall be concentrated in two or three
nunneries and in two or three monasteries for monks and they shall not be
allowed to leave those monasteries.
Tasks: comrade It.-gen. Pintilie Gheorghe will talk this matter over with
the minister of Cults, Stanciu Stoian, and with the Patriarch; all the material
regarding the Roman-Catholic problem shall be prepared by Tuesday, 29 March
1949; the monasteries shall be established where all the Roman-Catholic monks
can be concentrated.
Securitate major general V. Mazuru
(A.S.R.I., Stock D, file no. 10089, p.86)
It emerges that the Church was not only contemplative but also fighting. That
explains the measures taken against monks, who actively supported the anticommunist
struggle (as this Dictionary partly attests).
Categories of persons under surveillance (who "plotted against the democratic gains")
"The internal reaction, made up of
former industrialists and landlords, elements of the former bourgeois state
apparatus, retired officers, former policemen, clerics, members of sects,
former members of the so-called historical parties, Iron Guardists and capitalist
elements from the villages."
...In 1951, 417,916 persons were under surveillance, 5401 of who were arrested
for "inimical activity."
(A.S.R.I., Stock D, file 189, p.6-7 The White Book of Securitate, p.45)
Main directions of action of the political police: "exposing the imperialist espionage actions"
...They pursued both to obtain data and secret
information on the country's defense system and to provoke certain acts of
diversion and sabotage, to the end of determining the collapse of the internal
life and creating tension in society. Attempts were made to involve the Iron
Guardist groups that were active in the mountains in the activity of sabotage,
whereas the "Iron Guardists who had sought refuge in monasteries were
used for intelligence gathering, as couriers and for providing shelter to
parachuted spies."
The counterintelligence concerns of the Securitate then extended to the representatives
of the Roman and Greek-Catholic cults, as well as those of the religious sects,
all of whom were accused of anticommu'nist propaganda and espionage in favour
of the capitalist countries.
(A.S.R.I., Stock D, file 9604, vol.4, p.144 The White Book of Securitate, p.23)
Prof. PAUL CARAVIA